International Science Editing

International Science Editing
Providers of Premier Scientific Editing Services
We speak your language
International Science Editing Portuguese website International Science Editing Japanese website International Science Editing Chinese website
  • Home
  • Services
    • Editing Services
      • Standard Editing
      • Premium Editing Service
      • Multiservice Package
    • Submission Support Services
      • Graphing
      • Custom Illustration
      • Figure Formatting
      • Journal Specific Formatting
      • Manuscript Review
      • Response to Reviewers
      • Multiservice Package
      • Cover Letter Writing
      • Lay Summary
    • Translation
    • Promote Your Research
  • Create Your Order
    • Editing
    • Submission Support Services
      • Manuscript Review Service
      • Figure Formatting
      • Custom Illustrations
      • Graphing
      • Video Abstracts and Video Bytes
      • Journal Specific Formatting
      • Multiservice Package
      • Response to Reviewers
      • Cover Letter Writing
      • Lay Summary
    • Translation
    • Promote Your Research
  • Payment
  • Writing Tips
    • Latest Posts
    • Manuscript Preparation
    • Journal Selection
    • Peer-Review
    • Publication Ethics
    • Research Promotion
    • Submitting an Article
    • Abstracts
    • Cover Letters
    • Request for Revision
  • Customer Service
    • FAQs
    • Feedback from our Clients
    • Approved Provider of Editing Services
    • Terms of Service
      • Security Policy
      • Privacy Policy
      • Cookie Policy
      • Disclaimer
  • 访问我们的中文网页
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • How Our Service Works
    • Publishers
    • Approved Provider of Editing Services
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Archives / My paper was rejected. What are my options?

September 11, 2019 by Lisa Clancy

My paper was rejected. What are my options?

Almost every scholar has had a paper rejected. Journal acceptance rates are typically low, ranging from 5% for higher impact journals (e.g., The Lancet) to 69% for “pay-to-publish” open access journals (e.g., PLoS ONE), whose criteria exclude the perceived importance of the paper. However, most rejected papers ultimately go on to be published [see 1 and 2]. In this blog, we discuss what your options are if your paper is rejected and which is the path of least resistance to getting published.

You can appeal the decision

You should only use this option if you have unquestionable reasons for doing so.

If your paper was rejected for reasons related to the journal’s specific agenda—e.g., your paper is outside the scope of the journal, the journal recently published a similar paper or has a similar paper in their pipeline, the editor/reviewer believe your paper is of limited impact relative to other submissions, etc.—it is unlikely your appeal will succeed. Most journals do not have the capacity to publish every paper submitted to them and must reject many scientifically sound papers to prevent backlogs.

If your paper was rejected based on technical issues raised by the reviewers that you are certain are invalid, you can appeal. Present your argument as explicitly as possible, without repeating what was written in the original manuscript. Add new data to support your argument, if applicable. Revise the text in the manuscript to make your argument clearer, if applicable. If a reviewer misunderstood your point, it is likely a reader will also struggle. If you believe the reviewer is not competent enough to review your paper, politely and diplomatically request another referee be invited.

If you have clear evidence of unethical behaviour by the referee—e.g., conflict of interest, bias [see 3 for an example of sexism in a peer review report]—you can appeal.

It is your right as an author to appeal. However, there are a few important things to remember:

  • Appeals are rarely successful.
  • Appeals are given lower priority than new submissions, so it may take several weeks, if not longer [4], for a decision to be made.
  • Editors are busy people and you could be blacklisted as “difficult” by appealing their decision. This may be especially true if your appeal is later found to have been unsubstantiated.
  • If you decide to appeal, see [5] for an excellent list of do’s and dont’s.

You can transfer your submission to another journal

Some journals offer “portable peer-review”, whereby if your paper is rejected you can request your manuscript files, metadata, peer-review reports (along with reviewer identities, subject to agreement), and rebuttal letter be sent to another journal. Assuming the new journal is a better fit, this is a considerably faster route to publication compared to a fresh submission to another journal. This is also advantageous if you are concerned about ownership of any discoveries, as the original submission date is typically used, rather than the transfer date [6].

Your transfer journal options may be limited, however, as many journal do not offer portable peer review, and those that do, often only transfer to other journals by the same publisher (e.g., BMC). However, portable peer review may be on the rise, given the formation of the Life Science Alliance [7] and the announcement by BMC Biology that it will now allow authors to transfer to any journal of their choosing, including those outside of BMC and Springer Nature [8].

You may be concerned about transferring all the details of a previous rejection to an editor [as speculated by Philip Moriarty, professor of physics at the University of Nottingham in a Times Higher Education report 9], especially as you are not required to do so for fresh submissions. In fact, this misconception may be the reason for the poor uptake of portable peer-review by the scientific community. However, editors are typically “pleased to receive a manuscript that has been previously reviewed and revised because the paper is usually in better shape overall: more concise and clear” [10].

You can submit to another journal

This is the most common response to rejection; in fact, many authors opt for an “aim high, then drop if rejected” strategy, presumably unconcerned by the potential time delays [2]. To increase your chances of success, you should target a more suitable journal based on the initial reviewer/editor comments. As mentioned above, often scientifically sound papers are rejected for reasons related to the study’s perceived impact, e.g., if the paper is only a minor extension of a previous study. A lower tier or specialised journal is more likely to publish such studies. It is relatively rare to find a paper that is so fundamentally flawed it cannot be published anywhere [11]. For tips on choosing a journal, see our video blog How to choose a journal.

It is crucial that you amend your paper according to the reviewers’ comments where possible before submitting elsewhere, as there is a considerable chance that your paper could be sent to the same reviewers.

You can submit to a preprint server

Criteria for posting on a preprint server are much less restrictive; papers are only subject to a basic screening. Posting is free and fast, with papers typically accepted within 48 hours. Your paper will not be peer reviewed; other scholars can (openly or privately) comment on the content of an article after it has been posted. Authors typically submit to preprint servers prior to formal submission to a journal; however, you can upload any paper, even those that have been through peer review. Your preprint will be assigned a DOI, which formally date-stamps any claims or ideas made in your article and enables the indexing of preprints in databases such as Google Scholar and CrossRef.

References                                     

  1. The Grigorieff Lab. The Paper Rejection Repository. Available from: The Paper Rejection Repository [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  2. Duffy M. First cut results of poll on manuscript rejections: we deal with a lot of rejection. Dynamic Ecology. Available from: First cut results of poll on manuscript rejections [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  3. Bernstein R. PLOS ONE ousts reviewer, editor after sexist peer-review storm. Science. 2015 May 1. Available from: PLOS ONE ousts reviewer after sexist peer-review storm [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  4. When to dispute a decision. Available from: Springer guide: When to dispute a decision [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  5. Doerr A. How to write an appeal letter. Methagora Blog Nature Methods. Available from: How to write an appeal letter [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  6. JMIR Publications. Why has my article been transferred to another journal (or a transfer has been suggested), and what are my options? Available from: Article transfer guidance from JMIR [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  7. Kießling T. Publishing alliance comes of age. EMBO. Available from: Publishing alliance comes of age [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  8. Bell GP, Kvajo M. Tackling waste in publishing through portable peer review. BMC Biol. 2018;16:146. Available from: Tackling waste in publishing through portable peer review [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  9. Pells R. Journal shares peer reviews of rejected papers with rival titles. Times Higher Education. 2019 Jan 2. Available from: Journal shares peer reviews with rival titles [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  10. Sullivan GM. What to do when your paper is rejected. J Grad Med Educ. 2015 Mar;7(1):1–3. Available from: What to do when your paper is rejected [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].
  11. Durso TW. Editors’ advice to rejected authors: Just try, try again. The Scientist. 1997. 11:13. Available from: Editors’ advice to rejected authors [Accessed 5 Sept. 2019].

Filed Under: Archives, Latest Posts, Peer-Review Tagged With: appeal decision, article rejected, finding the right journal, open access, peer-review, portable peer review, preprint server, preprints, publishing, rejected paper, resubmit paper, transfer paper, which journal

Chinese website

访问我们的中文网页

我们会将您的手稿交给与您所在研究领域相匹配的英语母语学术编辑进行润色,他们将修正拼写,语法,标点和句法错误。 编辑还将改进句子结构,并确保使用符合科学论文写作的专业用语。

Trusted by Publishers and Societies

  • Society of Child Development
  • SAE International
  • American Society of Hematology
  • American Association for Nutrition
  • American Meteorological Society
  • American Society for Microbology
  • American Association for Mechanical Engineering
  • American Society of Civil Engineers
  • American Psychological Association
  • Association for Computing Machinery
  • American Academy of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery
  • American Society of Cancer Research

Price Calculator

Plan B written on 'enter' key on keyboard

My paper was rejected. What are my options?

Almost every scholar has had a paper rejected. Journal acceptance rates are typically low, ranging from 5% for higher impact journals (e.g., The Lancet) to 69% for “pay-to-publish” open access journals (e.g., PLoS ONE), whose criteria exclude the perceived importance of the paper. However, most rejected papers ultimately go on to be published [see 1 […]

Currency converter

European Office

Tel: +353 61 472818
International Science Editing
Compuscript Ltd,
Shannon Industrial Estate West,
Shannon, Republic of Ireland.

Chinese Office

Tel: 0512-67621565, 0512-87661520
International Science Editing
Room 2013, Locca Tower,
8th Jiarui Road,
Suzhou Industrial Park, Suzhou,
Jiangsu Province, China.
访问我们的中文网页

North American Office

Tel: 717-668-9325
International Science Editing
2930 Legacy Lane,
York,
Pennsylvania, 17402,
U.S.A.

Copyright © 2025 · INTERNATIONAL SCIENCE EDITING · ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Real Time Web Analytics
We’ve updated our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. These updates address new privacy regulations in Europe and apply to everyone who uses International Science Editing including clients, authors and partners.
Click on Settings to view the list of cookies, the different category headings, and/or change the default settings. Please click on “Accept” to continue to use International Science Editing Accept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

These cookies do not store any directly identifiable information. However, they are necessary for the Service to function. They are usually only set in response to actions made by you which amount to a request for services, such as setting your privacy preferences, logging in, or filling in forms. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies, but without these cookies, some or all of the services you have asked for may not work properly.

Analytics

Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.

Uncategorized

Undefined cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.

Performance

These are analytics and research cookies that allow us to count visits and measure traffic, so we can measure and improve the performance of our Services. They also help us to know which pages are the most and least popular and see how visitors move around the site(s) or application(s). This helps us to improve the way our Services work and improve user experience. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies. Blocking these cookies will not affect the service provided to you.

Preferences

Preference cookies are used to store user preferences to provide content that is customized and convenient for the users, like the language of the website or the location of the visitor.

Targeting

These files, or code may be included, either directly or from our advertising partners, on our website, in our emails, or mobile applications to record how you interact with us, to help us better analyse and improve our services to you, and will use this information to make the website, and, any advertising displayed to you more relevant to your interests. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies. Blocking these cookies will not affect the service provided to you but will limit the targeted advertising that you will see or limit our ability to tailor the website experience to your needs.

Save & Accept